I Thought I Saw the Promise of Forever in Your Eyes I Thought That I Was Sure of What I Saw You Led Me to Believe That I Was Special in Your Life So I Left My Heart Wide Open For the Fall What a Heartache You Turned Out to Be Chorus: What a Heartache, What a Heartache Love Ain't Always What It Appears to Be What a Heartache You Turned Out to Be I Thought I'd Found a Safe and Lovin' Place Inside Your Heart And I Was Warm and Willing Anytime The Same Soft Lips That Kissed Me Sweet Were Lyin' From the Start But I Swear I Thought Your Love Was Genuine What a Heartache You Turned Out to Be Chorus: What a Heartache, What a Heartache Like a Switchblade That Cuts Quick and Deep Ooo, What a Heartache You Turned Out to Be Bridge: It Just Goes to Show That You Never Can Tell I Really Thought That I Knew You Well I Still Can't Believe I Could Be Deceived So Easily Are All These Wishes I'm Wishin' to Myself Like Rusty Coins in a Wishin' Well Wishes Come True, They Come False As Well It's Too Late For You and Me Oh, What a Heartache, Ooo, What a Heart Break Love Is Two-faced and Easy to Believe Chorus: What a Heartache, Ooo, What a Heartache What a Mistake to Think I Could Believe Ooo, What a Heartache You Turned Out to Be Oh, What a Heartache You Turned Out to Be