I don't know your phone number
I don't think I ever did
I don't know if you love coffee
Or if you could live without it

Feels like we've been through war together
Feels like you've been right here forever
But I don't even know you at all

I don't know your favorite place to eat
Or what argument makes you square up to fight
I don't know your favorite way to sleep
Or if it changes every night

Feels like we've been through war together
Feels like you've been right here forever
But I don't even know you at all
At all
At all

I know more about your friends than I know about you
I know that they've placed their bets on us
But since we're through
They can keep their money
That they've wagered on our love
And maybe someday soon
Some of them will lose

But I don't know you
And I'm guessing that you don't know me
I don't know you
So how could we expect our love to come with ease

I could say that we were kids
But that just isn't true
I could say that we wanted to believe in something new
I could give a million reasons why
But they won't do
But in my heart
Feels like I have always known you

I don't know your phone number
I don't think I ever will
I don't care if you love coffee
Or if just one sip makes you feel sort of ill

Feels like we've been through war together
Feels like you've been right here forever
And that's the thing that matters most of all