I got people I can talk to
Almost everything's still the same
But for the first time in forever
Nobody wants to say your name
Now my story's getting longer
But nobody really knows about
All the ground that we covered
That I'm scared of walking over now

The last time I saw you
Was the first time it hit
You said: Don't be a stranger
What's stranger than this?

Can't sleep thinkin' about you now
Can we pretend that I shut my mouth?
I know I promise you that nothing would change
But whatever happened to always?

Stayin' up, we'd talk 'til the trains run
How come it's so easy to go from
Friends to lovers but not lovers to friends
And I know we can't have it both ways
But I miss the us from the old days

Went from growing up together
To watching us grow apart
In the search for something better
Did we lose the most important part?

The last time I saw you
Was the first time it hit
You said: Don't be a stranger
What's stranger than this?

Can't sleep thinkin' about you now
Can we pretend that I shut my mouth?
I know I promise you that nothing would change
But whatever happened to always?

Stayin' up, we'd talk 'til the trains run
How come it's so easy to go from
Friends to lovers but not lovers to friends
But I know we can't have it both ways
But I miss the us from the old days

And whatever happened to all those times we'd say
That whatever happens we'd always stay
Right here, hell and high water
It won't be weird, I can still call ya
Promised each other that nothing would change
So whatever happened to always?

Stayin' up, we'd talk 'til the trains run
How come it's so easy to go from
Friends to lovers but not lovers to friends
But I know we can't have it both ways
But I miss the us from the old days

I see you and act like I'm ok
But I miss the us from the old days